SciFigure AI logoSciFigure AI
Back to blog

For Researchers

Journal Club Presentation Template: Slide-by-Slide Guide and Example

A free 14-slide journal club presentation template (PPTX) with timings, an example outline, a critical appraisal checklist and how to redraw the key figures.

Nov 17, 2026SciFigure EditorialSciFigure Editorial
Journal Club Presentation Template: Slide-by-Slide Guide and Example

A journal club presentation has one job: to get a room of busy people to understand a paper well enough to judge it, and then to argue about it usefully. That makes it different from presenting your own work. You are explaining someone else's decisions, showing figures that were drawn for a printed page, and steering a discussion rather than defending a result.

This guide gives you a slide-by-slide template for that job, with timings for 30-, 45- and 60-minute slots, a worked example outline, a critical appraisal checklist matched to the study design, and a method for redrawing the paper's figures so they work on a screen.

Download the template: journal club presentation template (PPTX, 14 slides, 16:9). It opens in PowerPoint, Keynote and Google Slides. Every slide has placeholder text in square brackets, a suggested time, and speaker notes that say what the slide is for.

The journal club format in one table

SlidePurposeTime in a 20-minute talk
1. TitlePaper, authors, journal, year, DOI; you and the date0.5 min
2. Why this paperOne-sentence summary and why it matters to this group1 min
3. BackgroundOnly what is needed to understand the question2–3 min
4. Question and hypothesisThe question in one sentence; PICO for clinical studies1 min
5. Study design and methodsDesign, samples, groups, measurements, statistics, ideally as a schematic3–4 min
6–8. Key figuresOne finding per slide, each with a redrawn or cropped figure2–3 min each
9. Authors' conclusionsWhat they claim, set against what the figures showed1 min
10. StrengthsSpecific design features that make the result believable2 min
11. Limitations and biasWhat could be wrong and whether it changes the conclusion3 min
12. Take-home messageThree numbered points1 min
13. Discussion questionsOpen questions to start the conversationthe rest of the session
14. References and creditsThe paper, background sources, figure credits and licences—

These timings are our recommendation for a typical 20-minute presentation followed by discussion, not a rule from any society. Scale them to your slot, using the table further down.

The slide-by-slide template

Slide 1: Title

Put the full title, the first author with "et al.", the journal, the year and the DOI on screen. The DOI matters: it is how people who arrive late, or want to read along, find the paper. Add your name and the date.

Slide 2: Why this paper

Say in one sentence what the authors did and found, why the paper deserves the group's hour, and what you want the room to decide by the end. "Should we adopt this assay?" or "Would this change how we treat X?" gives the discussion a target from the start.

Slide 3: Background

Give the minimum the audience needs: two or three facts, with citations, and the gap the paper fills. A single schematic of the biology, the system or the clinical pathway usually does more than three slides of text. Leave the history of the field out.

Slide 4: The research question and hypothesis

State the question in one sentence, in the authors' terms, and their hypothesis. For clinical and epidemiological papers, break it into PICO: population, intervention (or exposure), comparator and outcome, plus the primary outcome. Writing this slide is the best test of whether you have understood the paper; you will check later whether the design actually answers the question.

Slide 5: Study design and methods

Cover the design (randomised trial, cohort, case-control, cross-sectional, experimental or computational), the subjects or samples with their numbers and selection, the groups and comparisons, the key techniques, and the statistics, including any power calculation and correction for multiple comparisons. A study-design schematic, with groups, intervention, time points and readouts, explains a design in seconds. Flag anything unusual here, but save your judgement for the appraisal slides.

Slides 6–8: The key figures

This is the heart of the talk, and where most journal club presentations go wrong by pasting a whole multi-panel figure onto one slide. Instead:

  • One finding per slide, written as a full-sentence slide title ("Drug X halved the relapse rate at 12 months"), not "Figure 2".
  • Orient before interpreting. Say what the axes are, what each colour or group is, what n is and what the error bars represent (SD, SEM or a confidence interval), then give the takeaway.
  • Choose two to four figures, the ones that carry the main claim. Mention the rest in a sentence, or keep them as backup slides for questions.

How to make those figures readable is covered below.

Slide 9: What the authors conclude

Summarise the authors' conclusions, close to their own words, then ask whether they follow from the figures you have just shown. That contrast between claim and evidence sets up the appraisal.

Slides 10–11: Critical appraisal

Split strengths and limitations onto separate slides, and be specific: name the design feature and say why it makes the result more or less believable. Use one appraisal checklist that fits the design (see the checklist section) and say which you used. Distinguish a flaw that could overturn the conclusion from a limitation the authors already acknowledge.

Slide 12: Take-home message

Three numbered points: what the paper shows, how far you trust it, and what it means for your group. If the room remembers nothing else, it should remember these.

Slide 13: Discussion questions

Prepare four or five open questions, more than you will need. Good ones ask the room to apply, extend or challenge the paper rather than recall it (there is a question bank below).

Slide 14: References and figure credits

List the paper with its DOI, any background references, the appraisal checklist with its version, and a credit for every figure you reproduced or redrew, with its licence.

How long should a journal club presentation be?

Most journal clubs split the time between the presentation and the discussion. Our suggested splits:

SlotPresentationDiscussionSlides from the template
30 minutes15 minutes15 minutes1–5, two key figures, 9–14 (about 12 slides)
45 minutes20 minutes25 minutesAll 14
60 minutes25–30 minutes30 minutesAll 14, with a fourth figure or a backup slide

Rehearse once out loud with a timer. Background and methods are the sections that overrun; if you are over time, cut background before you cut figures or appraisal.

Choosing the paper

The organisers of a long-running bioinformatics journal club, writing in PLOS Computational Biology, give advice that applies to any field: choose papers that are interesting to criticise, not only good ones; pick articles that are challenging but not too hard, avoiding very long or very dense papers; and let presenters choose topics they care about. They also recommend scheduling leaders and papers in advance so that people have time to read.

In practice, a good journal club paper is recent, relevant to most of the room, open access or easy to obtain, and short enough to read in an evening, with a central claim that reasonable people could disagree about.

Reading the paper to present it

  1. First pass: title, abstract, figures and their legends, conclusions. Write the one-sentence summary for slide 2.
  2. Second pass: introduction and methods, with the supplementary methods open. Fill in slides 4 and 5 and draw the design schematic.
  3. Third pass: results, figure by figure. For each, note what is plotted, the n and the statistical test, and whether the text claims more than the figure shows.
  4. Appraisal pass: work through the checklist for the study design, then write slides 9–12.
  5. Context: look for an editorial, published comments or a peer review file. Some journals publish the reviewers' reports, which often raise exactly the questions the room will ask.

How to redraw and simplify the paper's figures

Journal figures are built for a printed page read at arm's length; slides are read across a room. A figure that works at 180 mm wide in a PDF usually fails on a projector because the type is a few points high and six panels compete for attention.

  • Show one panel at a time. Crop the panel that carries the finding and enlarge it, or split a multi-panel figure across several slides.
  • Enlarge the text. Axis labels, tick labels and legends that were 6–8 pt in print need to be several times larger on a slide. If you cannot enlarge them in a cropped image, redraw the panel.
  • Redraw from the data when you can. Some journals publish the numbers behind each graph (Nature Communications, for example, asks authors for source data for every graph and chart), so you can replot a panel with larger labels, fewer colours and only the comparison you are discussing. Our scientific figure maker helps rebuild a clean panel or a schematic.
  • Simplify mechanism diagrams. Keep the main path and drop side branches you will not discuss. A one-slide visual summary of the whole paper, made with the graphical abstract maker, works well on slide 2 or 12.
  • Keep it editable. Export redrawn figures as editable slides or vectors rather than flat screenshots, so you can fix a label five minutes before you present; our editable export produces PowerPoint and SVG files you can change.
  • Label it honestly. Mark a redrawn panel "redrawn from [Author] et al., [Journal year], Fig. x", and do not change the data, scales or statistics. If you simplify, say what you left out.
  • Check the licence. Showing a figure inside an internal teaching session is a different matter from posting the slides online. Articles under a CC BY licence may be reused and adapted with attribution; for other articles, check the publisher's terms before sharing the slides beyond the room.

Critical appraisal checklist for journal club

Use the checklist that matches the study design. The CASP (Critical Appraisal Skills Programme) checklists are free and widely used in journal clubs; the reporting guidelines collected by the EQUATOR Network tell you what a well-reported paper of each design should contain.

Study designAppraisal checklistReporting guideline to compare against
Randomised controlled trialCASP RCT checklistCONSORT (2025 update)
Cohort studyCASP cohort study checklistSTROBE
Case-control studyCASP case control checklistSTROBE
Cross-sectional studyCASP cross-sectional studies checklistSTROBE
Systematic review or meta-analysisCASP systematic review checklistsPRISMA
Diagnostic accuracy studyCASP diagnostic study checklistSTARD
Qualitative studyCASP qualitative studies checklistSRQR
Clinical prediction rule or modelCASP clinical prediction rule checklistTRIPOD+AI
Economic evaluationCASP economic evaluation checklistCHEERS
Animal research—ARRIVE

The CASP checklist for randomised trials (2024 version) is a good model of how to structure the appraisal. It asks four groups of questions, which we paraphrase here:

  1. Is the basic design valid? A clearly framed question in PICO terms; genuinely random assignment with concealed allocation; every participant accounted for at the end, analysed in the group they were randomised to, and an explanation if the trial stopped early.
  2. Was the study methodologically sound? Blinding of participants, investigators and outcome assessors; groups similar at baseline; groups treated equally apart from the intervention.
  3. What are the results? Effects reported fully, with a power calculation, clearly specified outcomes, relative and absolute effects, missing data and drop-out explained, and confidence intervals for the precision of the estimate; and whether the benefits outweigh the harms and costs.
  4. Will the results help locally? Whether the results apply to your population or setting, and whether the intervention would add value over what you already do.

CASP's advice for using its checklists applies to every journal club: never assume the authors did something they do not report. If you cannot tell, record "can't tell"; many of those answers are a finding in themselves.

For laboratory and basic-science papers, where no CASP checklist fits, ask:

  • Are the controls the right ones (positive, negative, vehicle, isotype, loading)?
  • Are replicates biological or technical, and how many independent experiments were there?
  • Do the statistics match the design (paired or unpaired, correction for multiple comparisons, n defined as the right unit)?
  • Was quantification blinded, and were images chosen as representative?
  • Do the images look unaltered, with uncropped blots in the supplement?
  • Does each conclusion follow from an experiment, or from an inference across several?
  • Are the data and code available?

A journal club example outline

The example below is invented to show how the template reads when it is filled in; the study is not a real paper.

SlideExample content
1. Title"Early mobilisation after hip fracture surgery: a randomised trial". Presenter, date, DOI
2. Why this paperOur ward is reviewing its post-operative protocol; the trial reports fewer complications with mobilisation within 24 hours. Question for the room: would we change our protocol?
3. BackgroundImmobility after surgery is linked to complications; earlier trials were small or non-randomised
4. QuestionP: adults over 65 after hip fracture surgery. I: mobilisation within 24 hours. C: usual care (48–72 hours). O: complications at 30 days (primary), length of stay, mortality
5. MethodsMulticentre RCT, 400 patients, central randomisation, outcome assessors blinded, intention-to-treat analysis, power calculation for the primary outcome
6. Key figure 1"Complications at 30 days fell from 24% to 16%": a bar chart with absolute numbers and the 95% CI of the difference
7. Key figure 2"Length of stay was one day shorter": a box plot redrawn from the supplementary data
8. Key figure 3"No difference in falls": the safety outcome, shown because harms matter
9. ConclusionsAuthors recommend mobilisation within 24 hours for all patients; does the evidence cover patients with dementia, who were excluded?
10. StrengthsConcealed allocation, blinded outcome assessment, low loss to follow-up, pre-registered primary outcome
11. LimitationsParticipants and physiotherapists could not be blinded; usual care varied between centres; the exclusions limit applicability
12. Take-home1. Early mobilisation reduced complications in this trial. 2. The design was sound; applicability is the main question. 3. Pilot it for patients who meet the trial's criteria.
13. DiscussionWould our staffing allow mobilisation within 24 hours? Should patients with dementia be included? What would we measure in a pilot?
14. ReferencesTrial, background sources, CASP RCT checklist (2024), figure credits

Discussion question bank

  • Does the design answer the question on slide 4, or a slightly different one?
  • Which single result would you most want to see replicated, and how?
  • What is the most likely alternative explanation for the main finding?
  • Is the main figure the clearest way to show this result? How would you redraw it?
  • Who was excluded, and would the result hold for them?
  • If you were a reviewer, what one additional analysis or experiment would you ask for?
  • Would this change what we do in our lab or clinic? What would it take to convince us?

Common journal club mistakes

  • Presenting the paper section by section instead of building the argument; the audience wants the question, the evidence and your judgement.
  • Pasting whole figures with unreadable text, then reading the legend aloud.
  • Agreeing with the authors for twenty minutes and leaving no time or material for critique.
  • Critiquing everything equally, so that a missing decimal place gets the same weight as a confounder that could explain the result.
  • Running out of time for discussion, which is the point of the meeting.

Before you present: a checklist

  • The paper and the date were circulated far enough ahead for people to read it.
  • Slide 2 states a question for the room to decide.
  • The methods slide has a design schematic and the numbers.
  • Each figure slide shows one finding, with readable text and a full-sentence title.
  • Strengths and limitations come from a named checklist that fits the design.
  • Three take-home points and at least four discussion questions are ready.
  • Every reproduced or redrawn figure is credited, and the licence is checked if the slides will be shared.
  • Colours read correctly for colour-blind viewers; check redrawn figures in the colorblind simulator.
  • You have rehearsed once with a timer.

Frequently asked questions

What should a journal club presentation include?

The paper's question, its design and methods, the key figures, the authors' conclusions, a critical appraisal of strengths and limitations, a take-home message and questions for discussion. The 14-slide template above covers each in order.

How many slides should a journal club presentation have?

About 12 to 15 for a 20-minute presentation: one each for the title, rationale, background, question, methods, conclusions, strengths, limitations, take-home message, discussion and references, plus two to four for key figures.

How long should a journal club presentation be?

It depends on the slot, but leave at least as much time for discussion as you can: roughly 15 minutes of presentation in a 30-minute slot, 20 in a 45-minute slot and 25–30 in an hour.

Is there a journal club PowerPoint template?

Yes: download our free journal club presentation template. It is a 16:9 PowerPoint file with 14 editable slides, suggested timings and speaker notes, and it opens in Keynote and Google Slides too.

How do I critically appraise a paper for journal club?

Use a checklist that matches the study design, such as the CASP checklists, and compare the paper with the matching reporting guideline (CONSORT for trials, STROBE for observational studies, PRISMA for systematic reviews). Separate flaws that could change the conclusion from limitations that only narrow it.

Can I use figures from the paper in my journal club slides?

For an internal teaching session, showing a credited figure is common practice. If you will post or share the slides, check the licence: CC BY articles can be reused and adapted with attribution, while other articles may need permission. Redraw panels where you can, and credit the source either way.

How do I choose a paper for journal club?

Pick a recent paper that is relevant to most of the group, readable in an evening and interesting to criticise, ideally one whose main claim reasonable people could disagree about.

What is the difference between a journal club and a lab meeting?

At a lab meeting you present your own data and ask for help with it; at a journal club you present someone else's published work and lead the group in judging it.

Sources

Checked 17 November 2026.